Every renewable installer gets the calls. "We've got solar leads in your area." "Heat pump enquiries, ready to go, pay as you go." Some of those offers are decent. Many are not. The trouble is they all sound similar on a sales call, and you usually find out which kind you have bought after a month of wasted surveys.
These five questions work for any kind of solar lead provider or heat pump lead supplier: a lead seller, a pay-per-survey outfit, or an agency running ads for you. For each one we have set out what a good answer sounds like, the red flags, and how to check the answer rather than take it on trust. If you are specifically weighing up shared leads, our shared vs exclusive solar leads post has a quick checklist too. This one goes deeper.
1. "Show me exactly what the homeowner saw and agreed to."
This is the question most installers forget, and it matters most. The ad and the landing page decide what the homeowner thinks they are getting. If the ad hinted at free panels or a free heat pump, your rep inherits that promise on the first call.
A good answer: They show you the actual ads, the landing page, the form questions and the consent wording. Better still, the ads feature your business, your installs and your people, so the homeowner knows who will call.
Red flags:
- "We can't share our creative, it's proprietary."
- Generic ads with no installer named, promising "government-funded" or "free" systems.
- Consent wording that lets the lead be passed to "selected partners".
How to check: Ask for screenshots of the last three ads that ran in your area. Then fill in the form yourself from a spare email and phone and see what happens next, and who else calls you.
2. "Who else gets this lead, and for how long?"
Exclusivity is one of the biggest factors in how well bought leads close. A lead sent to four installers becomes a race to dial and a price war.
A good answer: In writing: each lead goes to you and only you, it is never resold later as an "aged" lead, and the provider does not run campaigns for a competing installer in your postcodes.
Red flags:
- "Exclusive for 24 hours."
- "Semi-exclusive" or "limited share".
- No answer on whether they work with other installers in your area.
How to check: Ask new leads on the first call: "Have any other companies been in touch about this?" Log the answer in your CRM for the first 50 leads. You will know within a fortnight. At Attain, leads are 100% exclusive, never shared or resold, and we work with one installer per area.
3. "What makes a lead valid, and what happens when one isn't?"
Every provider qualifies differently. Some ask nothing beyond name and number. Others ask about ownership, property type, heating fuel, roof direction, bills and timescale. The definition of a valid lead decides what you pay for.
A good answer: They show you the qualifying questions, agree a written definition of a valid lead, and have a clear credit or replacement process for wrong numbers, renters and duplicates.
For heat pumps, the qualifying questions should cover the things that decide grant eligibility and suitability: home ownership, current heating fuel, property type and age, and whether it is a new build. Our post on pre-qualifying heat pump leads lists them.
Red flags:
- "All our leads are qualified" without saying how.
- Credits only for "invalid numbers", which excludes most of the real problems.
- A credit process that takes weeks of emails.
How to check: Ask for the full list of form fields. Then look at what actually arrives. If the lead record is just a name, phone and postcode, it was not qualified, whatever the sales pitch said.
4. "What will you report on beyond the lead?"
Any provider can report leads delivered. What you need to know is what those leads became: surveys booked, surveys sat, sales, installs and cost per sale. A provider who only talks about cost per lead is measuring the thing that matters least to you. We explain why in cost per lead is the wrong number for solar installers.
A good answer: They want your survey and sales outcomes, ideally connected from your CRM, and they use them to improve targeting. An agency running ads for you should feed booked surveys and sales back to Meta and Google so the platforms learn which homeowners buy.
Red flags:
- Reports that stop at "leads delivered".
- No interest in which leads became sales.
- Defensiveness when you raise poor-quality leads.
How to check: Ask what their monthly report contains and request an anonymised example. Ask how they will know which of their leads you sold.
5. "What do I own, and what happens if I leave?"
This is about whether you are building an asset or renting one. If you stop paying a lead seller, the leads stop and you are left with nothing. If an agency builds ads, pages and data in accounts they own, you may lose those too.
A good answer: Clear contract terms with a short notice period, and, for agency work, your ads, pages, pixel data and customer list sit in accounts you own or can take with you. Our post on whether you own your website and ad accounts covers what to check.
Red flags:
- Long lock-ins before you have seen a single result.
- "We own the landing pages and the data."
- Vague answers about what you keep if you leave.
How to check: Read the contract before you sign, not after. For context, our own terms are one month minimum to start, reviewed together at the end of month one, then monthly rolling with 30 days' notice.
How to run a fair trial
Even with good answers, the leads have to prove themselves. Run any new provider like this:
- Agree definitions first. Valid lead, booked survey, sale. In writing.
- Tag every lead by source in your CRM the moment it arrives, so nothing is judged from memory.
- Call every lead fast and the same way. Otherwise you are testing your own team, not the leads. Our post on why installers misjudge lead quality explains how to keep the comparison fair.
- Track by month of enquiry until each lead has bought or died, which for solar and heat pumps can take several weeks.
- Compare cost per sale, not cost per lead, against your margin.
Use a simple scorecard:
| Measure | Provider A | Provider B | Your own campaigns |
|---|---|---|---|
| Leads | |||
| Contact rate | |||
| Surveys sat | |||
| Sales | |||
| Total spend | |||
| Cost per sale |
If you are deciding between paying per lead, paying per survey or building your own campaigns, our comparison of pay per lead, pay per survey and your own lead flow sets out the trade-offs. And for what a good lead looks like in the first place, see what makes a good solar or heat pump lead.
The answer we give
Ask us the same five questions. We will show you the ads and funnel before anything goes live, the leads are exclusive with one installer per area, the qualifying questions are agreed with you, reporting runs to cost per sale through our CRM, and the contract is monthly rolling after month one. Night & Day Renewable Energy moved from buying heat pump leads to running their own campaign with us, at £28.24 per air source heat pump lead, and grew turnover from £200k to £650k+ in twelve months. See how our lead generation works for solar and battery and heat pump installers.
Want to put your current provider to the test?
Book a free video call with Tom. Bring what you are paying now and what it has produced, and we will help you work out your real cost per sale and whether your area is open.
Questions owners ask
What is a reasonable trial with a new lead provider?
Long enough to follow leads through to sales, which for solar and heat pumps usually means at least two to three months of enquiries, tracked until each one has bought or died. Agree in advance what counts as a valid lead, how you will report surveys and sales, and how you can stop if the numbers are poor.
Should a lead provider guarantee a number of sales?
Be careful with anyone who does. Sales depend on your speed, your sales process and your prices as much as on the leads. A provider can be accountable for lead quality, contactability, exclusivity and reporting. A promise of guaranteed installs usually means the small print redefines what a lead or a sale is.


