Ask an installer which of their lead sources is best and you will usually get a confident answer. Ask how they know and the answer is often a feeling: the last few calls, the rep who keeps complaining, the job that came in from a source everyone had written off. Close rates are supposed to settle the argument. Often they make it worse.
This post is about one specific mistake: treating close rate as a measure of lead quality. It is not. Close rate measures lead quality and how well your business handled the lead, mixed together. Until you separate the two, you will cut good sources and keep paying for bad ones. (If you want the basics of what a good close rate looks like and which denominator to use, start with what's a good close rate for home improvement sales?. This post assumes you have that sorted.)
Three ways installers misjudge lead quality
1. Judging by memory
People remember the extremes. The homeowner who swore at your rep, the renter who wasted a survey, the £18,000 solar and battery job that closed in one visit. A source that produced one memorable disaster gets labelled "rubbish" even if it quietly produced six installs. Memory is a terrible sample.
2. Judging by the rep's opinion
Reps are not neutral. A rep who has not called a lead back for three days will tell you the lead was poor. A rep who prefers warm referrals will find fault with every cold enquiry. That is not dishonesty, it is human. But it means the person working the lead is also marking its homework.
3. Judging by close rate alone
Close rate is the end of a long chain: contact, conversation, booking, survey, quote, follow-up, decision. A lead can die at any link. If it dies at "contact" because nobody rang for six hours, that is a handling failure, but it still shows up as a lower close rate for the source.
What close rates hide
Here is what a single close rate figure cannot tell you:
- Speed. Leads contacted in five minutes and leads contacted next morning are counted the same.
- Effort. One call attempt and eight call attempts look identical in the final figure.
- Who worked it. If one rep gets most of the leads from source A, you are judging the rep, not the source.
- Timing. Solar and heat pump buyers often take weeks to decide. A source launched last month always looks worse than one that has been running for a year, because its leads have not had time to close.
- Job value. A source closing 20% at £16,000 a job beats one closing 30% at £6,000.
- What happened after the sale. Cancellations, finance declines and jobs that fall over at the design stage rarely get subtracted.
A worked example
Here is an illustrative example, not a real client. An installer runs two sources for three months. The owner looks at close rate on sat surveys and sees this:
| Source A | Source B | |
|---|---|---|
| Leads | 200 | 200 |
| Close rate on sat surveys | 40% | 25% |
Source A looks far better. Now add the rest of the chain:
| Source A | Source B | |
|---|---|---|
| Leads | 200 | 200 |
| Contacted within 15 minutes | 30% | 75% |
| Average call attempts on unanswered leads | 2 | 6 |
| Surveys sat | 20 | 60 |
| Sales | 8 | 15 |
| Average job value | £9,000 | £12,000 |
| Revenue per lead | £360 | £900 |
Source B produced nearly twice as many sales and two and a half times the revenue per lead. Its close rate on sits is lower because more of its leads got far enough to be surveyed, including some marginal ones. Source A's high close rate is partly survivorship: only the keenest buyers made it through slow, patchy follow-up.
The owner was about to cut Source B.
How to separate lead quality from lead handling
Use reason codes for every dead lead
When a lead is marked lost, the CRM should force a reason from a short fixed list. Free text is useless for reporting. A list that works for renewables:
- Never contacted (wrong number, no answer after the full attempt sequence)
- Not the homeowner or not the decision-maker
- Property unsuitable (roof, space, listed building, flat)
- Not eligible for the grant or finance they expected
- Just researching, no timescale
- Price too high after seeing a figure
- Chose another installer
- Went quiet after quote
Reasons 2, 3 and 4 point at the lead. Reason 1 might be either: check the attempts and speed before you decide. Reasons 6, 7 and 8 mostly point at your sales process, your quote or your follow-up. Once you have 50 or more dead leads per source with reasons, the pattern is usually obvious.
Check contact speed and attempts before blaming the source
Pull time to first contact and number of attempts for each source. If one source is consistently being called slower, that is the first thing to fix, and the comparison is not fair until you do. Our post on the 5-minute rule covers why speed changes outcomes so much.
Rotate leads across reps
If you can, share leads from each source fairly across reps for a month. If source A closes well for one rep and badly for another, it is a rep issue. If it closes badly for everyone, it is probably the lead. Setter and sales team reporting goes into how to see this per person.
Judge by month of enquiry
Group leads by the month they came in and follow each group until every lead has either bought or died. Never compare this month's sales with this month's leads in a business where jobs take weeks to close.
Better signals of lead quality than close rate
These show up earlier and are harder to argue with:
| Signal | What it tells you about the lead |
|---|---|
| Contact rate (after a full attempt sequence) | Are these real people who expected a call? |
| Ownership and decision-maker confirmed | Can this person say yes? |
| Survey booked within 7 days | Is there genuine intent? |
| Survey sat rate | Did they still want it when the day came? |
| Average job value quoted | Are these buyers of full systems or small add-ons? |
| Lost reasons 2 to 4 as a share of leads | How much of the source is unqualifiable? |
If a source scores well on these but closes badly, look at the sales stage. If it scores badly on these, no amount of better selling will save it. Whether you need more leads or better ones is its own question, covered in lead quality vs lead volume.
Set the CRM up to answer the question
None of this works from a spreadsheet updated on Friday afternoons. You need the source captured automatically when the lead arrives, every call attempt logged, the stage updated as it moves, and lost reasons made compulsory. Then the report builds itself.
That is how we set up Installer Flow, our CRM, for solar, battery and heat pump installers: every lead tagged with its source and ad, every attempt timed, and dashboards showing cost per survey and cost per sale by source and by rep. For context, Eco Green Energy Group close 5 in 10 booked appointments, and that number means something precisely because the booked appointments are tracked properly.
For the wider method of tying spend to sales across every channel, see which marketing actually makes you money.
Want a second opinion on your lead sources?
If you are about to cut a lead source, or keep one on gut feel, book a free video call with Tom. Bring three months of leads with their outcomes and we will help you work out whether the problem is the leads, the handling, or both.
Questions owners ask
Is a low close rate always a sign of bad leads?
No. A low close rate can come from slow contact, too few call attempts, a rep who struggles with one type of buyer, or quotes that go out late. Before blaming the source, check how quickly each lead was contacted, how many attempts were made and why each lost lead was lost. Only then judge the leads themselves.
How many leads do I need before judging a lead source?
Enough that one good or bad week does not swing the answer. For most installers that means at least 50 to 100 leads from the source, followed until each one has either bought or clearly died. For solar and heat pumps that can take six to ten weeks, so judge by month of enquiry, not month of sale.


