Sales

Pay per lead, pay per survey or your own lead flow: which model helps installers scale?

Pay per lead, the pay per survey model or your own lead flow? A balanced comparison for solar and heat pump installers, with a worked cost per install example.

Tom Spink · Founder, Attain Digital · 21 November 2026 · 8 min read
Pay per lead, pay per survey or your own lead flow: which model helps installers scale?

There are three common ways for a solar, battery or heat pump installer to fill the diary with paid-for work: buy leads, buy booked surveys, or build your own lead flow with your own ads and funnel. Each model has people who swear by it and people who got burned. Most of the arguments are really about something else: who carries the risk, who controls the message, and what you are left with if you stop paying.

This post compares the three models fairly, without naming any provider. It does not try to declare one winner for everybody. It gives you a way to work out which one suits your business now, and which one will let you grow.

The three models in plain terms

Pay per lead. A provider runs ads or forms and sells you the contact details of homeowners who enquired. You pay for each lead, whether or not it turns into anything. You do all the contacting, qualifying and booking.

Pay per survey (or pay per appointment). A provider generates the enquiry and books a survey into your diary. You pay for each survey, usually much more than for a lead. Terms vary on whether you pay when it is booked or only when it is sat.

Your own lead flow. You run ads in your own name, to your own landing page or funnel, and your team or an AI assistant follows up and books surveys. You pay the ad platforms directly, plus whatever it costs to run the campaigns, whether in-house time or an agency.

Side-by-side comparison

Pay per leadPay per surveyOwn lead flow
What you pay forEach enquiryEach booked or sat surveyAd spend plus running costs
Who carries the risk of poor adsYouMostly the providerYou (or your agency's results)
ExclusivityVaries, often sharedVaries, check the termsExclusive to you
Control over what the homeowner was toldLowLow to mediumFull
Speed to startFastFastA few weeks to build
Cost predictabilityPredictable per lead, unpredictable per salePredictable per surveyVaries month to month
Booking and follow-up work for your teamHighLowMedium (lower with automation)
What you keep if you stopNothingNothingYour brand, reviews, content, customer data, ad account history
Ability to scaleLimited by supply in your areaLimited by supply and priceLimited mainly by budget and capacity
Data to improve targetingNoneNoneFull, if your CRM feeds back to the platforms
Best suited toTopping up a quiet patchTeams with no time to chaseInstallers who want to grow and own their pipeline

A worked example: cost per install under each model

Here is an illustrative example for a solar and battery installer, not a real client. Replace every figure with your own. Assume each lead costs £5 in setter time to work, and each sat survey costs £120 in surveyor time, travel and design.

Pay per leadPay per surveyOwn lead flow
Unit price£35 per lead£250 per sat survey£5,000 ad spend
Leads or surveys bought200 leads32 surveysabout 220 leads
Surveys sat403245
Sales8811
Provider or ad cost£7,000£8,000£5,000
Lead handling£1,000£0£1,100
Survey cost£4,800£3,840£5,400
Running cost (in-house or agency)£0£0add your figure
Total before running cost£12,800£11,840£11,500
Cost per install before running cost£1,600£1,480£1,045

Three honest caveats:

  1. The own-lead-flow column has a cost the table leaves blank. Someone has to build and run the campaigns, the funnel and the follow-up. Add that figure before you compare.
  2. Month one rarely looks like this. Your own campaigns need a learning period. Bought leads and surveys deliver from day one.
  3. Close rates are not fixed. Shared leads tend to close worse because you are racing other installers, and surveys booked by someone else's script can carry promises you did not make. Your own exclusive leads tend to close better, but only if you contact them fast.

The point of the table is the method. Put all three models through the same sum, cost per install including your team's time, and the right answer for your business usually becomes obvious.

What to check with pay per survey

The pay per survey model sounds like the safest option: you only pay for real appointments. It can work well. Before you sign, pin down:

  • Booked or sat? Paying for booked surveys means you pay for no-shows.
  • Who booked it, and what did they say? A setter paid per booking has every reason to book marginal homes and gloss over price.
  • What was qualified? Ownership, roof or heating type, property type and, for heat pumps, Boiler Upgrade Scheme eligibility.
  • Is the survey exclusive? Some homeowners are booked in with more than one installer.
  • What happens with disputes? If the homeowner says they never wanted a survey, do you still pay?

Our five questions to ask any lead provider covers these in more depth.

When each model makes sense

Pay per lead suits you if you have a fast, disciplined sales team, you need a quick top-up in one area, and you track every lead to a sale so you know if it is worth it. If you go this way, read shared vs exclusive solar leads first.

Pay per survey suits you if you have no one to chase leads, you need predictable costs this quarter, and the price per survey still leaves a healthy margin after your close rate.

Your own lead flow suits you if you want to grow beyond a few jobs a week, you want leads nobody else gets, and you are willing to invest in the set-up: a landing page that qualifies, fast follow-up, a CRM that tracks every stage, and someone in the business willing to be on camera. It is the only one of the three where what you build keeps working for you.

Moving between models without an empty diary

Most installers who switch do it gradually:

  1. Keep your current source running.
  2. Launch your own campaign alongside it in part of your area.
  3. Track both by month of enquiry, through to installs.
  4. Shift budget towards whichever produces the lower cost per install over two to three months.

That is what two of our clients did. Wiltshire Energy, a solar and battery installer, went from 3 surveys a week to 15, booked off their own campaign instead of bought-in leads. Night & Day Renewable Energy, an air source heat pump installer, moved from buying leads to their own campaign and grew turnover from £200k to £650k+ in twelve months.

For a deeper look at keeping surveys steady week after week, see building a predictable survey pipeline.

How we approach it

We build installers their own lead flow: exclusive leads, one installer per area, a qualifying funnel, AI booking and follow-up, and reporting to cost per sale. Our contract is one month minimum to start, reviewed together at the end of month one, then monthly rolling. See how our lead generation works for solar and battery and heat pump installers.

Want to compare the models with your own numbers?

Book a free video call with Tom. Bring what you spend on leads or surveys now and what it produces, and we will run the same cost per install sum with you, and check whether your area is open.

Questions owners ask

Is pay per survey better than pay per lead?

It moves some risk to the provider, because you only pay when a survey is booked or sat. In exchange you usually pay much more per unit and have less control over what the homeowner was told. It suits installers who want predictable costs and little set-up. Judge it on cost per install, not on how safe it feels.

How long does it take for your own lead flow to work?

Enquiries usually start the week a campaign goes live, but the first month or two is a learning period while ads, qualifying and follow-up are tuned. Solar and heat pump sales then take weeks to close. Most installers run their own campaigns alongside existing sources at first and shift spend as the numbers prove themselves.

Tom Spink
Tom SpinkFounder of Attain Digital. Over ten years running Google and Facebook ads, the last five specialising in renewables and home improvement. About Attain Digital →

Book a video call

Let’s talk about growing your business

No hard sell. No pressure. A straightforward conversation about your business, your area, and whether we can help. If it is a fit, we will explain exactly how the system works. If it is not, we will tell you straight.

Calendar not loading? Open it in a new tab.

Rather message first?
Message Tom on WhatsApp
Book a call